Review – Praetorian by Simon Scarrow

Praetorian by Simon Scarrow

Publisher: Headline

Publication date: November 2011

 

Hardcover 368 pages

Also available as paperback, Kindle e-book and audio download

 

Review:

Book 11 in Simon Scarrow’s Roman Legion series, Praetorian continues the adventures of army veterans Macro and Cato. While Cato has grown up a lot over the series, he remains the intellectual and the idealist, while Macro continues to be a grumpy realist. In this episode, set in Rome in AD 50, the duo are manipulated by Narcissus into going undercover in the Praetorians to root out a conspiracy, a role they are don’t feel trained for. Starting again as mere legionaries, albeit in the prestigious Praetorians is a strange feeling after a long time in command, but they soon get their teeth into a plot that threatens to starve Rome, and topple the Emperor.

It never takes me long to finish off one of Scarrow’s book, partly because of “unputdownability,” and partly because the writing style is very easy to read. A light sprinkling of humour, together with puzzles and action make his books highly entertaining, and this book doesn’t disappoint, with no sign of the series running out of steam.

As characters such as Britannicus, Nero and Tigellinus are introduced, I wonder if Scarrow plans on extending the series into Nero’s reign, or even, with Vitellius making another appearance, into the year of the Four Emperors, which would be a thrilling time for  Macro and Cato to be involved with. I fear though that Macro would be pretty ancient in terms of continuing active service 19 years from the time this book is set though.

I will review some of the earlier books in this series in due course. This isn’t necessarily the best place to start reading the series. However, the very first book, while a good starting point, isn’t my favourite. If you don’t intend to read all 11 books, but want to jump into the series a bit earlier, consider reading The Gladiator, or a bit earlier, The Eagle’s Prophecy.

Alex Gough July 2012

 

 

Graffiti from Pompeii (parental advisory)

The Romans were a fairly earthy lot, so please don’t read on if you are easily offended…

A selection of graffiti to be found on the walls of Pompeian buildings: 

Fortunatus you sweet little darling you great fornicator, someone who knows you writes this.

Figulus loves Idaia

G. Julius Promogenius was here on time, what’s keeping you?

Jarinus had a girl here with Athetus

You’ve had eight jobs; now it only remains for you to double the list and make it sixteen. You’ve been a pub-waiter, you’ve made pottery, you’ve dealt in salted fish, you’ve done bakery, you’ve been a farmer, you’ve made small bronze oddments, you’ve been a street-hawker, now you make little flasks. If only you’ll hire yourself out to the ladies, you’ll have fun the whole gamut.

The petty thieves ask you to elect Vatia as city magistrate

Macerio and those who sleep a lot ask you to elect Vatia as city magistrate

All the late drinkers ask you to elect Marcus Cerrinius Vatia as city magistrate

Secundus says hello to his Prima, wherever she is. I ask, my mistress, that you love me.

Weep, you girls.  My penis has given you up.  Now it penetrates men’s behinds.  Goodbye, wondrous femininity!

The one who buggers a fire burns his penis

Chie, I hope your hemorrhoids rub together so much that they hurt worse than when they ever have before!

Floronius, privileged soldier of the 7th legion, was here.  The women did not know of his presence.  Only six women came to know, too few for such a stallion.

Antiochus hung out here with his girlfriend Cithera.

On April 19th, I made bread

I admire you wall, for not having collapsed at having to carry the tedious scribblings of so many writers

References:

Basement Geographer

Butterworth & Lawrence (2005) Pompeii, the living city. Orion Books Ltd, London

Graffiti from Pompeii

Lindsay. J. (1961) Ribaldry of Rome. Paul Eleck Ltd London

McKeown, J., (2010) A Cabinet of Roman Curiosities. OUP

Quick guide to Roman Authors

Quick guide to Roman fiction authors:

A list of the major authors of Roman fiction, past and present (plus one aspiring one, see if you can spot which one that is!). This list is a work in progress – I will update with titles, a summary of subgenre and writing style (for those I have read) and even some links. Watch this space…

William Altimari

 

Nick Brown

 

Peter Darman

 

Lindsey Davies

Author of the Falco mysteries, set in Vespasian’s Rome.  Gentle humour combines with vivid detail of life in the lower echelons of Roman society.

Paul Doherty

 

Richard Foreman

 

R S Gompertz

 

Goscinny and Uderzo

Rene Goscinny and Alberto Uderzo created the famous Asterix children’s cartoons, and wrote them together until Goscinny’s death in 1977, after which Uderzo continued the series. Set in a Gaulish village that resisted Julius Caesar’s Gallic conquests by virtue of the strength imbuded by a magic potion brewed by the village’s druid, Asterix and his friend Obelix (who has permanent strength because he fell in the cauldron of magic potion when he was a baby) undergo various adventures throughout the Roman Empire during the last days of the public. Littered with historical facts, Latin phrases and modern references, the adventures of Asterix and Obelix remain a delight to any adult with a childish sense of humour interested in Ancient Rome. A comfort read that I would return to again and again throughout much of my childhood and adult life, I am delighted to be reading the stories with my daughter now.

Alex Gough

 The owner of this website (and a veterinary surgeon). My first published novel, Five Emperors, set at the end of Nero’s reign and the civil war of AD 69, was published as an e-book in 2001 by Romance Foretold Inc, on floppy disc, in an era before the kindle and ipad. It was then released as a paperback by print on demand, shortly before the company went bust. It is now available on Smashwords, but I am considering republishing on Amazon. More important to me currently is my work in progress, not currently titled, about Carbo, a veteran of the Roman legions. Set in Tiberius’ Rome, the first book in what I hope will be a series finds Carbo  involved with an escaped slave, the vigiles, a Carthaginian priestess and a plot that threatens Rome itself.

Robert Graves

Scholar, poet and author of two books often considered to be among the top 100 English language books ever written: I, Claudius, and its sequel Claudius the God. Although Graves professed to dislike the books and wrote them only for financial need, they became bestsellers from their publication in the 1930s, and were adapted into a highly successful BBC TV series. Graves also produced a well-regarded translation of Suetonius’ Twelve Caesars.

Robert Harris

Author of Pompeii, a story set prior to and during the eruption of Vesuvius, and two books on Cicero’s life, Imperium and Lustrum (Conspirata in the USA and Italy) with a third scheduled for release in 2012. Scholarly but gripping, the works are well worth a read. 

Conn Iggulden

 

Douglas Jackson

 

Ben Kane

 One of three veterinary surgeons in this list writing Roman fiction. Ben Kane is author of the Forgotten Legion trilogy, set at the time of Crassus’ disastrous military campaign against the Parthians. He is also author of Hannibal, Enemy of Rome and Spartacus, the Gladiator. I am currently reading the Forgotten Legion – so watch this blog for more comment!

Caroline Lawrence

 

Ross Leckie

Lord Lytton

Oldest Roman fiction author in this list, his book the Last Days of Pompeii was a bestseller in the 19th century.

 

James Mace

 

Allan Massie

Author of Augustus, Tiberius and Caesar, fictionalised diaries of the three rulers. Written with insight and thoughtfulness, these books help to bring the reader closer to what the historical characters may have really been like.

Antoinette May

 

Colleen McCullough

Author of the Masters of Rome series, a lengthy, fantastically detailed and meticulously historically accurate account of the fall of the Roman Republic, from the early days of Marius and Sulla to the death of Caesar. Highly recommended for anyone with a genuine love of the history of these times. Readers looking for a quick thrill or an easy read might find the material too dense.

Sophie McDougall

 

Kate Quinn

 

Anthony Riches

Author of the Empire series, centred around the fugitive, Marcus Valerius Aquila, who flees the tyranny of Commodus Rome to a posting on Hadrian’s Wall. Genuinely exciting and well written military fiction.

Steven Saylor

Author of the Roma sub Rosa series, a detective series set in Republican Rome, featuring Gordianus the Finder. Also author of the books Roma and Empire which follow the fortunes of a family from the foundations of Rome through to Imperial times.

Simon Scarrow

Author of the Eagle series, involving legionaries and firm friends, Cato and Macro and their military adventures, often working for Narcissus, secretary of Claudius. Easy to read, exciting and humorous, these books are a great place to start reading Roman military adventures.

Manda Scott

The third vet in this list, and author of the Boudicca trilogy, as well as Rome: The Emperor’s Spy, Rome:The Coming of the King, and the Eagle of the Twelfth. Currently on my soon to be read list – watch this space. 

Harry Sidebottom

 Author of the Warrior of Rome Series, set in the later Imperial period, and centred around the Roman military leader of Germanic origin, Ballista. When asked to sum up the series in ten words, the author came up with, “Ballista, Warrior of Rome, Hard Action, High Scholarship, Low humour.”

John Stack

Author of the Masters of the Sea series, Ship of Rome, Captain of Rome and Master of Rome, gripping military adventures set in the first Punic War.

Rosemary Sutcliffe

Author of the Eagle of the Ninth series, centred around the famous disappearance of the IXth legion in Scotland. Aimed at teenagers, the stories can be enjoyed by adults, and inspired the film The Eagle. 

SJA Turney

Author of the Marius’ Mules series.

Henry Venmore-Rowland

 

Thornton Wilder

 Author of the classic work, the Ides of March,  a series of letters written by Caesar in the lead up to his assassination. A commentary on Mussoloni, in the authors words it is: ‘a fantasia on certain events and persons of the last days of the Roman republic… Historical reconstruction is not among the primary aims of this work’

 

Books and authors on my reading list

Anthony Riches, Empire: The Leopard Sword

Ben Kane, Forgotten Legion

S J A Turney, Marius’ Mules I: The invasion of Gaul

Douglas Jackson, Caligula

Robert Fabbri, Vespasian: Tribune of Rome

Manda Scott: Rome: The Emperor’s Spy

Got a few others in the library too, but I think that is plenty to be getting on with!

My favourite Roman authors

My favourite authors in no particular order. I will be reviewing books by these authors in the near future.

Colleen McCullough

Simon Scarrow

Anthony Riches

John Stack

Steven Saylor

Lindsay Davies

Allan Massie

Robert Harris

Ross Leckie

Robert Graves

Goscinny and Uderzo 🙂

Harry Sidebottom

Rosemary Sutcliff

Thornton Wilder

New website

So I’m starting to construct the new website, using wordpress to make it easier to edit and update. With reviews of Roman fiction, articles and photos about Ancient Rome, and information on my work in progress (working title Carbo of Rome), I am hoping this site will appeal to fans of Roman fiction and Ancient Roman history everywhere.